top of page

Global Bookkeeping Week: The Pioneering Use of the Double-Entry Bookkeeping System for the Willoughby Accounts in the 17th Century

5 days ago
5 min read

The 16th-20th November 2026 is Global Bookkeeping Week, which aims to celebrate the bookkeeping profession. Middleton Hall has a unique and unusual pioneering claim to fame in the history of bookkeeping. During the period of executorship, after the death of Francis Willughby FRS in 1672, the bookkeeping style of the estate accounts was changed to the double-entry system. This is believed, with almost certainty, to be the oldest known surviving example of the use of this technique in England for non-commercial purposes and mining activities.


Until the death of Francis Willughby, the Willoughby estate accounts had been kept in the conventional charge-and-discharge method. This traditional method for keeping account books focused almost entirely on cash flowing in and out. Although Francis was a brilliant academic and mathematically adept, he was also well renowned for getting easily distracted by his academic pursuits. It was described that the accounts at the time of his death were a confusing mess and in such a state of disarray that the family’s actual financial survival was at risk.


In the double entry system, every transaction is recorded twice with equal and opposite entries, known as debits and credits. Essentially, if money moves, it must come from somewhere and go to somewhere. This created the modern notion of “balancing” the books. Alongside this, journals acted as a detailed diary, making it possible to audit and trace every single transaction.


The invention of the modern version of double-entry bookkeeping is credited to a 13th century Florentine merchant. However, it was historically used strictly, but extensively, for business interactions by Italian, and then other European, merchants. In England, it was not until the mid-18th century that the double-entry system began to be commonly more widely applied. However, double-entry did not become the dominant form of accounting until the mid-19th century.


One of the five executors of Francis Willughby was his father-in-law Sir Henry Barnard. Sir Henry was described as a Turkey merchant and he traded with the Ottoman Empire via the Levant Company. In 1673, he radically changed the Willoughby accounts style to the double-entry system. It is believed his business experience with Mediterranean merchants explains why he was well-versed in the Italian double-entry system. For its time, the accounting style he applied to the Willoughby accounts was an uncommonly sophisticated and accurate system.


Sir Henry began first with a simple Cash Book. This was then incorporated into the new Ledger. It was written that Sir Henry had initially intended that the Ledger would just be a record of the monetary transactions of Francis Willoughby, the son and heir of Francis Willughby FRS. However, it quickly developed into much more due to the complexity of the various obligations, types of income sources and multiple manors.


Portrait of Francis Willoughby (son of Francis Willughby FRS). Painted by John Riley (1646-1691). Photograph taken by Glen Segal, 2021. Courtesy of Lord Middleton.
Portrait of Francis Willoughby (son of Francis Willughby FRS). Painted by John Riley (1646-1691). Photograph taken by Glen Segal, 2021. Courtesy of Lord Middleton.

This first account in the Ledger was followed by another for Francis Willughby’s widow Emma. An account for their second son Thomas was then made and then ones for the two illegitimate sons of Sir William Willoughby, Hugh Willoughby and Richard Revell. All of these individuals had been left specific portions of the Willoughby Estate. There was also a current account for a London banker who handled the accounts.


The accounts began with all of the payables and credits at the time of Francis Willughby’s death in order to determine liabilities and assets. No entry was made for any non-monetary items such as land or chattels. This confirms that rather than being a wealth valuation, his system was purely focused on tight financial control of monetary assets.


However, those simple fund accounts then encountered problems. One of the reasons for these problems was the income from rents from the various manors in the Willoughby portfolio. Many tenants paid rents that had specific, legally binding deductions attached to them. To solve this, Sir Henry created subsidiary books for the manors. It listed each tenant's name, their total rent, and five precise columns that recorded the: rent paid; deductions; taxes; receipts; and arrears. The final calculation provided a mathematically perfect total rent, which was then fed directly into the main Ledger.


This method was then expanded to the commercial activities on the manors. It was first applied to the massive coal-mining operations. This was done by recording the income from sales and offsetting it against the expenses of pit-sinking and other fees. The total was then added to the Ledger. This method was later also applied in the same manner for timber sales.


Second, it was applied to the farms on their lands. The Willoughby family did not directly farm on any of their lands but let them all to tenants. These tenants then paid half-yearly rents directly to the steward. The payments were recorded in the charge-and-discharge form, in which the charge represented the collected rent values and the discharge covered the upkeep of the properties, taxes paid and remits. Sir Henry converted all of the charge and discharge entries into debit and credit with counterpart entries in the accounts for the relevant manor. For the first time on an English estate, income was not recognised until credits exceeded debits.


Sir Henry’s system was not perfect. It lacked periodic balancing, failed to close accounts regularly, did not provide neat half-yearly or yearly income breakdowns and it was not broken down to any individual beneficiary. Moreover, the books were never actually balanced at any time from when they were begun in 1673 until they were superseded in 1676.


Middleton Hall volunteer on Entrance at Middleton Hall, 2026. Photograph taken by Janine Waldron.
Middleton Hall volunteer on Entrance at Middleton Hall, 2026. Photograph taken by Janine Waldron.

In 1676, Sir Henry Barnard hired Thomas Godfrey, accountant, to “perfect” the accounts. The use of the occupational title is intriguing because it did not yet exist as a profession. At that time and traditionally, the term specifically referred to someone who rendered the accounts in charge-and-discharge form. This was definitely not the meaning in this context.


Godfrey was not well-renowned, had few to no models to guide him and yet managed to establish a system for the Willoughby accounts that two centuries later became accepted as general accounting principles. He completely remodelled Sir Henry’s system into five separate ledgers, each with its own journal and capital account. This extremely advanced and effective setup successfully managed complex cross-transactions, multi-county properties, oversight of charities, expensive litigation, trust cash flows and investments.


However, the use of this pioneering system was short-lived. After the death of Sir Henry Barnard in 1680, control of the Willoughby estate accounts fell to his daughter Emma and her new husband Sir Josiah Child. She abandoned this progressive use of the double-entry system in about 1681, returning back to the traditional charge-and-discharge method.


Further Reading:

Geoffrey A. Lee, "The Francis Willughby Executorship Accounts, 1672-1682: An Early Double-Entry System in England," The Accounting Review, 56:3, July 1981, pp.539-553, https://www.jstor.org/stable/246914


Author - Debbie Jordan, Middleton Hall Volunteer.


Comments


bottom of page